The African Group has proposed several initiatives that call for “policy space for industrial development” based on “re-balancing” the existing World Trade Organization rules in order to promote their own industrialization, said people familiar with the development.
With six months left before the WTO’s 13th ministerial conference commences in Abu Dhabi in February 2024, the WTO seems to be embroiced in a clash of narratives on WTO reforms.
According to paragraph three of the Outcome Document of the WTO’s 12th ministerial conference held in June 2022, WTO members are required to work towards “necessary reform of the WTO” based on the “foundational principles (enshrined in the Marrakesh Agreement of 1994) of the WTO.”
The reforms are envisioned to improve all the functions of the WTO including the negotiating function, the enforcement function and the implementation and monitoring function.
At a time when the major industrialized countries, including the United States and the European Union among others, seem to be resorting to national industrialization policies in apparent
violation of WTO rules, the African Group of more than 50 developing countries is seeking the “re-balancing” of the WTO rules to enable them to industrialize in different areas.
The six proposals tabled by the African Group on July 5 highlight six different themes with a central message: reform of the organization must begin with addressing the mandated issues
that have been hanging in limbo for more than 23 years.
Impact of Industrialization
They touch upon issues that have remained unaddressed since the fourth ministerial conference in Doha, Qatar, in November 2001.
The proposals by the African Group appear to drive home the message that it is time that “charity begins at home” namely at the WTO, in the area of “re-balancing” the WTO rules, unlike
pursuing unilateral industrialization initiatives worth billions of dollars like the US Inflation Reduction Act of 2022, which seeks to provide subsidies for developing green industries; the US
CHIPS Act of 2022 that allegedly aims to perpetuate the US hegemony in advanced digital areas; and carbon border tax measures as recently put in place by the EU.
At a time when the WTO is being increasingly attenuated by the United States to ensure that there is no robust two-tier dispute settlement system, and the sudden plunge into controversial
plurilateral discussions involving the Joint Statement Initiatives, the African Group said what they are seeking is a mere “re-balancing” of the existing WTO rules that would allow them to
pursue their own specific industrialization paths.
Proposals
The six proposals circulated by the African Group touched on the following themes:
1. The role of transfer of technology in resilience building – “Reinvigorating the Discussions in the WTO on Trade and Transfer of Technology (WT/GC/W/883);
2. The role of transfer of technology in resilience building – The TRIPS Agreement (WT/GC/W/884);
3. The role of transfer of technology in resilience building Agriculture (WT/GC/W/885);
4. The role of transfer of technology in resilience building – Climate Change Adaptation, and Mitigation (WT/GC/W/886);
5. The role of transfer of technology in resilience building – Trade Facilitation (WT/GC/W/887);
and
6. The role of transfer of technology in resilience building – The Work Program in Electronic Commerce (WT/GC/W/888).
According to the African Group, an examination of the role of transfer of technology in trade was mandated by trade ministers at the fourth WTO ministerial conference in Doha in 2001.
The discussions highlighted that “technology and technical know-how were essential for improving productivity, promoting growth, and attaining the development aspirations of less developed Members; and, that technology transfer can be an important tool to narrow the technological gap between developed and developing countries, and for integrating developing countries into the multilateral trading system.”
Several cross-cutting issues have emerged in the WTO, particularly due to a health crisis in the form of the COVID-19 pandemic, food insecurity and climate change. The African Group said, “WTO rules on the transfer of technology are relevant in the context of the TRIPS Agreement.”
It said that the COVID-19 pandemic is the latest illustration of “how WTO rules and the so-called flexibilities in the TRIPS Agreement have hampered Members’ ability to respond reasonably to the multiple crises that ensued.”
Moreover, the COVID-19 pandemic has “prompted a deeper reflection on the utility of the TRIPS Agreement vis-a-vis the manufacturing capacity of developing and least developed countries
notably in the pharmaceutical and industrial sectors.”
Therefore, it said the reinvigoration of the discussions in the TRIPS Council would “delve deeper into the relationship between the promotion and dissemination of technology in way that benefits
both its producers and users.”
The African Group said the role that digital technologies play “in trade facilitation reform is an area of growing interest to WTO Members.”
It said this paves the way for a deeper reflection on the effects of digital technologies on the composition of trade especially in developing and least developed countries.
Technology
Further, such reflections indicate how “intellectual property protections together with other institutional and regulatory determinants could affect the smooth transfer and diffusion of
technology to developing countries, including least developed countries.”
Faced with the continuing “poly-crises (a term coined by the former European Commission head Jean-Claude Juncker for multiple crises at any point of time)”, the African Group said that “the transfer of technology is fundamental when considering how to build agricultural resilience to withstand, amongst others, the food security emergencies.”
Noting that technological developments including hybrid seed, fertilizers, pesticides, mechanical improvements, etc. have revolutionized agricultural trade in industrialized countries, the African Group said that state intervention played a key role.
Given the predominant role that international and regional agriculture research centers play in promoting and disseminating technology, the African Group said it is important to know “how
products and technologies are developed (inputs, production, harvest, etc.), as well as considering a range of issues relating to water management, nitrogen, and food waste reductions, etc.”
According to the African Group, “WTO Members will greatly benefit from resetting the climate change narrative in the WTO to an assessment of the application of existing WTO rules on
technology transfer for diffusion of climate change technologies, including compulsory licensing.”
Environmental Law
It wants the discussions at the WTO to “focus on how to build deeper coherence and coordination to support existing mechanisms and frameworks” in the context of emerging environmental law principles.
The EU’s carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM) could act as the biggest barrier for developing countries trying to carry on with their industrialization, said a person who asked not
to be quoted.
Even though the 1998 Work Programme on Electronic Commerce has provided a broad framework for discussion in an area of extreme importance; i.e., the safety and cybersecurity of
hardware and software systems through Source Code, the major players appear to have circumvented the discussions on several important issues in the e-commerce work program, said people familiar with the discussions.
The African Group said that the discussions on the E-commerce work program should “assess the policy and legal considerations of balancing accessibility to source codes in the context of a secure, transparent and trusted technology environment.”
The African Group said the themes could be based on the following parameters:
A. Analyzing the relationship between the transfer of technology and economic development.
This may include but is not limited to:
I. Assessing the role of technology transfer in increasing production and in enhancing agricultural productivity in developing and least developed countries.
ii. Assessing the role of Transfer of Technology as a means to enhancing industrial development and in diversifying their economies to better integrate into the regional and global value chains, including in the green economy.
B. Assessing the use of Information and Communications Technology (ICT) to promote technology transfer.
C. Assessing the role of the "flexibilities" contained in the TRIPS agreement to promote technology transfer in areas relevant to pharmaceuticals and medical applications, treatments,
medicines, diagnostics, therapeutics, and biodiversity.
D. Assessing the role of the "flexibilities"contained in the TRIPS agreement to promote technology transfer in areas relevant to climate change mitigation, decarbonization or green
industrialization technologies, and digitalization.
E. Assessing the role of technical assistance and capacity-building programs offered or granted by donors to developing and least developed countries, including an examination of technology
transfer flows.
F. Identification and assessment of incentives provided by developed countries, by virtue of their national regulations, to their enterprises and institutions to promote and encourage technology
transfer to developing countries and in particular to LDCs (Article 66.2).
G. How to best enable MSMEs (micro, small, and medium enterprises), especially in developing and least developed countries benefit from various technology transfer tools, instruments,
agreements and platforms?
H. Assessing the effects of the introduction of patents on prices and welfare in developing and least developed countries (the case of pharmaceuticals and therapeutics).
In a crux, the African Group’s comprehensive proposals call for a robust and fundamental “re-balancing” of the existing WTO rules.
However, it remains to be seen how the African Group intends to invest its negotiating energies at the WTO and whether it will be able to change the terms of the debate on WTO reforms.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here